CamaroMan,
The recoils you pictured from EBay are both for water-cooled Elgins. The one you have is air cooled and takes a different recoil. Yours would be vented to allow cooling air to flow through it. I have a motor similar to yours that is a pretty good runner. Unfortunately, I don’t have a spare recoil, but below is a picture of what I believe the one you need would look like.
-Ben
OldJohnnyRude on YouTube
