Home Forum Ask A Member Polishing Machine

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #289897
    T….in Wisconsin
    Participant

      US Member

      Asking for advice on polishing machines.

      Things to consider and what brands are reliable.

       

      T…

      #289954
      The Boat House
      Participant

         

         My experience – When I began having an interest in mechanical things dad had arbor. I used one up till the 70’s. + Changing pulleys would change the speed. –  Not enough power. Belt slips. Takes up a lot of room. I put the motor under the bench and cut a slot for the belt but made changing pulleys difficult and its always there. Bought a grinder from Sears. Too slow and not enough power for buffing. Struggled with it till about 15 years ago. When a Harbor Freight open a store near me I bought a lot of stuff and it was mostly all junk. I buy my rubber cloves there and my polishing compound but that’s about it. However I still look around. I got a 3 ton aluminum jack out the door for $69.00 +, and its been OK. They had this buffer on sale for $40.00 and for that price I thought I would give it a try.   Better than anything I have had in the past but – not nearly enough power for the size buffing wheel that comes on it. It does better with a 5″ wheel and the best with a 4″ wheel, but you cant find them. You cant find ( or I cant anyway) wheels that fit the shaft, but most wheels come with adapters where you can get something to work. I left the grinding stone on as the rotating mass helps. I make a pile through the winter of stuff that needs polishing. Then on a nice day I’ll put the buffer on my bench and roll it outside. It’s dirty work and I often look like a coal miner when I’m done for the day.  In the 15 +/- years I have had it, I run it for 4 to 6 hrs.,2 to 4 days a year. Its worth the $40.00 paid for it IMO. They want a lot more for them today. Are they better – same – or worse? How long will mine last? Real buffers are $500.00 on up and I just don’t do enough of it to justify that kind of expense. Tubs

        #289961
        T….in Wisconsin
        Participant

          US Member

          I’ll look around on Market Place, not in a big hurry yet.

          Thanks Tubs

          #289966
          joecb
          Participant

            US Member

            Tubs, looking at the photo, the HF machine appears to be a purpose made buffer having the extended shafts rather than a “re-labled” grinder. What speed (RPM) does it run? I don’t know what the recommended speed ( FPM – feet per minute) ) is for buffing, but I’m thinking that it is considerably slower than FPM for a grinding wheel. To achieve a slower FPM speed on a buff of any good diameter, will require a slower RPM motor that still had the power to pull a buff wheel… that can get to be an expensive motor.

            I’ll do some research on proper FPM speed for buffing.

            Joe B

            #289978
            T….in Wisconsin
            Participant

              US Member

              Good questions Joe.

              Tubs notes the Sears grinder was too slow and not enougth power suggesting desired buffing speed is higher than that of grinding.

              Seems I recall finding some information on speeds, I’ll see if I can find it.

              Buffing wheels: Any recommendations on where to buy, are the HF wheels any good?

              T….

               

               

              #290003
              joecb
              Participant

                US Member

                With a little searching I found information on recommended buffing speeds.  Speeds of 3600 to 7500 FPM seem to be the sweet spot.

                for an 8 inch wheel at 3600 RPM that gives 7200 FPM.  That is faster than I would have thought, but that is what is suggested.

                Joe B

                #290008
                The Boat House
                Participant

                   

                  I did some checking on Grainger’s sight. Both buffer/polishers and grinders, that I looked, run either 3450 or 3600 RPM. The FPM would be determined by the size of the wheel and would become less as the wheel ( both polishing and grinding) became smaller. You want the speed to create heat when polishing soft metals. As the metal expands it brings the imperfections up to where you can buff them out, or reduce them, depending on how deep they are. After you strip all the stuff off a grinder, without the extended shaft, its really difficult to do large parts, like gear cases, or gas tanks. If you’re just polishing jewelry a $50.00 Harbor Freight grinder would be adequate IMO.  My experience is only with an arbor, one grinder, and a $40.00 buffer. There are so many options that I have no experience with and know nothing about. I suspect that if you spend $500.00, $1000.00, $1500.00 or more for a polisher,  it would likely perform better than and a $40.00 buffer, but its just my opinion as I only have experience with a $40.00 buffer. Tubs

                   

                   

                   

                   

                  #290022
                  T….in Wisconsin
                  Participant

                    US Member

                    I appreciate the feedback.

                    I’m looking for a budget conscious option for polishing. I consider the extended arbor as a must have for ease of presentation & safety.

                    Market Place is a good place for this type of stuff, one just needs to keep an eye out.

                    T…

                     

                     

                     

                     

                  Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
                  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.