That one looks factory, Tubs. Oddly, the recoil orientation is still perpendicular to the boat axis. ❓
That one does have the foam air filter though. Dig that crazy jet drive too. Looks as if the silver color is correct, but then the rototiller engine was the same silver and the rest of the OP’s outboard is natural metal colors of aluminum and copper.
I guess prototype is a possibility. As far as the workmanship, it is very clean. I would have to imagine this was built by a machinist / toolmaker and not by the average guy in his garage with a vise and a file. With decent equipment that level of workmanship is completely attainable with a bit of talent and pride in one’s work.
-Ben