Home Forum Ask A Member 64 Evinrude 28HP pops out of reverse

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 23 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #278100
    bob-d
    Participant

      US Member

      Ok here is a bit of unusual one? Don’t most motors pop off of forward due to a bad clutch dog? My motor pops out of reverse. Possibly the previous owner had the problem in forward and reversed the dog? I adjusted the cable to make sure it was going into full reverse, and the shift lever running down lower unit seems to working properly.
      Before I open up the gear case (I picked up a new clutch dog and reverse gear) is there any other parts that I should look at for wear, or adjustment?

      Thanks,
      Bob D

      IMG_2981

      #278104
      fleetwin
      Participant

        US Member - 2 Years

        OK, when you say pops out of reverse, just what do you mean?  Does it pop out of gear and stay out of gear?  Or, does it chatter and try to stay in gear?  There are alot of links/connectors etc here, so the stack up of slop can lead to “lost motion”.   Have you checked the fine adjustment on the shift handle?  Perhaps those fasteners are loose.  How about removing the control cable and shifting the shift lever manually into reverse, will it stay in reverse now?

        Keep in mind that the control box and cable can be a big source of trouble as well.  Excessive slop in lousy cables, or bad cable core connections can lead to lost motion as well.  Don’t rip into that gearcase until you have ruled out all the other possible issues.

        #278109
        bob-d
        Participant

          US Member

          Don, when I shift into reverse with my Simplex that I rebuilt with all new parts (below), if I don’t hold it in reverse it comes out of gear.
          Good point…..let me disconnect the cable, and just try using the shift lever on the motor and see what happens.
          Only problem in upstate NY, I have to wait for the darn rain to stop. It has been ridiculous, every day for weeks.

          Thanks,
          Bob D

          IMG_2982

          #278112
          fleetwin
          Participant

            US Member - 2 Years

            OK, let us know what happens.  I just don’t want you ripping that gearcase apart for nothing.

            #278169
            lindy46
            Participant

              A bad clutch dog/gear usually causes problems at higher speeds than you’d go in reverse. I’d suspect a cable or shift rod adjustment problem. Are your cables new?

              1 user thanked author for this post.
              #278207
              bob-d
              Participant

                US Member

                Lindy. I believe the cables are original 1964 vintage? I picked up the boat two years ago, and really don’t know its parts replacement history.
                At that point I rebuilt the Simplex, and removed and lubed the inner wire cables. They looked ok, the barrel connections held tight, no binding….. etc?
                I haven’t  been able to get out in the boat (rain every day) and try Dons wonderfully simple test of just disconnecting the shift cable and put the boat manually in gear and see what happens. If it works, then I will start chasing down linkage and cable slop.
                Thanks,
                Bob D

                #278220
                lindy46
                Participant

                  If Don’s idea works, then I’d replace the shift cable (actually I’d replace both). If it’s an original shift cable, who knows the condition. If someone has cut the inner cable slightly off, it will reduce the range of motion and cause the problem you describe.

                  1 user thanked author for this post.
                  #278285
                  bob-d
                  Participant

                    US Member

                    Ok reporting back. I tried Dons method, removed the shift cable, and shifted the motor manually. It stayed in gear for about 10 seconds then popped out. No chattering just went into neutral. If I held the lever in reverse it worked fine.
                    Will look at the indents / spring on the shifter lock. Maybe the reverse is worn out and it’s not holding? I’ll also double check the shift rod connection.
                    If anyone else has any ideas I’m open for any and all suggestions.
                    Thanks,
                    Bob D

                    #278291
                    billw
                    Participant

                      US Member

                      Divide and conquer is definitely the way to go. You have eliminated the control box and cables as your main problem. MY next step would be to pull the shift cover off the exhaust housing and grab hold of the shift rod and/or connector….maybe with needle nose vise grips….and try to limit up and down motion of the shift rods, while trying to move the shift lever back and forth. You would be checking for excessive lost motion in the linkage under the power head. I used to see some bad wear up there, sometimes. IF that checks out okay, loosen up the shift handle on the horizontal shift shaft, so it is free to move within its adjustment range. Don calls this “the fine adjustment.” Now, move the shift rod up and down, through full engagement, forward and reverse, and see if that adjustment is always within an obtainable place. (Now you’d be checking for excessive lost motion in the gear case.) I’m not sure how to better explain that. What I am trying to say is that if shift rod travels up and down more than the shift handle and shaft can travel, then you have a gear case problem, in my opinion. You might find a bent or worn shift fork, wrong size clevis pin, (I have seen it) etc. You may also have a worn out FORWARD gear, and someone over-adjusted the fine adjustment, to over-compensate for it, which leaves you short on travel in reverse.

                      Long live American manufacturing!

                      1 user thanked author for this post.
                      #278296
                      fleetwin
                      Participant

                        US Member - 2 Years

                        Heed Bill’s advice, “lost motion”/slop could be the issue here.  One more simple thing to try.  Have an assistant hold that vertical shift detent out of the way against its spring pressure.  Now spin the prop and shift into reverse to the engine its travel in reverse.  Does the shift lever’s pin travel way past where the vertical detent rod would normally position it in reverse?  If so, then I would suspect lost motion/slop as the issue.

                        1 user thanked author for this post.
                      Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 23 total)
                      • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.