Yes, there is a big difference between brand new parts going together at the factory and sealing up old crusty pieces….The fit is always nice when going together at the factory, which is why they didn’t need to use sealer………..But, I would not use sealer in between the SS plate and aluminum impeller housing…The SS plate surface can be cleaned up nicely, as can the impeller housing…I wouldn’t use sealer because you don’t want it to ooze out into the pump cavity and mess up the impeller performance…