My 7.5 gave me similar problems. I pulled the foot apart with some force and found the prop shaft had rusted to the bearing. I wound up getting a new shaft from a good parts motor, replaced the bearings and seals and now its good. The lower unit definitely looks bent on yours though. The 5 hp is the only one I don’t have. I have the 3.5, 7.5 and 10 hp but the 5hp seams to be a little more rare up hear in the Toronto GTA area.I am slowly restoring the entire set to running. 7.5 runs, 3.5 and 10 hp are well underway. Send me a PM and I will forward you the scott attwater manuals in PDF format. They are available somewhere on line but getting harder to find. The Firestone is a re branded early scott with slightly different covers.